Not as good as book one and two. The end made it a four star or I would have rated it a three. It was WAY to damn preachy and really went out on a limb. I had to go and read it again after listening to it on my Fire HD. I was ready to pull my hair out I was so blown away with how far it went off the deep end. I am really glad I went and re-read it. I felt like it was, again, way to preachy and the ghosts were a nice touch in the first two books but this book man... oh man. I will be reading the story about Rune and maybe I will like that part better. ANYWAY the series is amazing!